The Duel

London Calling. London Walks connecting. This is London. This is London Walks. Streets ahead. Story time. History time.

Four gentlemen. Four swords. An early November morning in Hyde Park.

Before it’s over, two of those gentlemen will be dead.

And one of them, it has to be said, had been asking for it for years.

His name was Charles Mohun. Lord Mohun. An English aristocrat, a member of the House of Lords, a soldier, a politician and an almost unbelievably disreputable character.

A rake. A bully. A drunk. A duellist. A man with a remarkable talent for being present when other people got killed.

He’d been tried for murder. Twice.

Acquitted. Twice.

He’d escaped the gallows, escaped punishment, escaped the consequences of his behaviour.

But on the morning of November 15th, 1712, his luck finally ran out.

And that’s our London story today.

Now, to get the measure of Charles Mohun, we need to go back a bit.

He was born around 1675, into the aristocracy. Money, rank, privilege. All the advantages.

Except, perhaps, good parenting.

His father died when Charles was very young. And here’s a grim little piece of family history: his father had been mortally wounded in a duel.

Yes, a duel.

It seems the Mohuns had a rather unfortunate family tradition.

Young Charles inherited his title while still a toddler. And growing up, he appears to have had precious little in the way of restraint.

By his teens, he was drinking, gambling, quarrelling and drawing his sword.

In December 1692, when he was about seventeen, he quarrelled over a game of dice. The authorities tried to keep him confined to his lodgings.

Fat chance.

He got out and fought a duel.

And just two days later, he was mixed up in something much worse.

A murder.

The victim was William Mountfort, a popular London actor.

Now, this is quite a story in itself.

Mountfort was an actor of considerable reputation. His wife was an actress too. And another celebrated actress,

Anne Bracegirdle, had attracted the unwanted attentions of a certain Captain Richard Hill.

Hill was jealous. Furious, in fact, because he believed Bracegirdle favoured Mountfort.

And Hill had a friend.

Lord Mohun.

The two men went looking for Mountfort.

When they found him in a London street, swords were drawn. There was a confrontation. And Captain Hill ran Mountfort through.

The actor died.

Hill fled.

Mohun was arrested.

And now we have one of those scenes that tells you an enormous amount about the England of the time.

A seventeen-year-old aristocrat, implicated in a killing, brought before his fellow peers for trial in Westminster Hall.

The proceedings were a sensation.

Fashionable London turned out to watch.

And Mohun?

Acquitted.

Sixty-nine votes to fourteen.

One contemporary even suggested that instead of all this judicial ceremony, somebody ought to take the boy away and give him a good whipping.

Well, they didn’t.

And it might have saved everybody a great deal of trouble if they had.

Because Charles Mohun wasn’t finished.

Not remotely.

There were more quarrels. More duels. More drunken escapades.

A confrontation with a coachman in Pall Mall. Another duel. A fight in St James’s Park. A death in a tavern brawl.

And then, in 1698, another fatal encounter, this time in Leicester Square.

A Captain Richard Coote was killed.

Mohun found himself facing another murder trial.

And once again, he walked free.

To be fair, the evidence in that second case didn’t establish that he had started the quarrel. And he apparently expressed remorse.

But look at the pattern.

This is a man who seems to have regarded the streets of London as his own private battlefield.

If somebody offended him, out came the sword.

If somebody died, well, there were lawyers, powerful friends and the privileges of rank.

The curious thing is that Mohun wasn’t simply some drunken wastrel.

He could be brave. He served in the army in Flanders. He took part in politics. He spoke in the House of Lords.

He belonged to the fashionable Kit-Cat Club, which brought together some of the leading Whig politicians and literary figures of the day.

Though even there he managed to make an impression.

On one occasion, he broke a chair.

The club secretary reportedly remarked that a man who would do such a thing would cut a man’s throat.

Not, perhaps, the most reassuring testimonial to a new member.

Anyway, let’s bring our man forward to 1712.

He’s now in his thirties.

And he has a new enemy.

A very grand enemy.

James Douglas, the fourth Duke of Hamilton.

The two men are locked in a bitter dispute over an inheritance.

Land. Property. Money.

A complicated legal wrangle involving the estate of the Earl of Macclesfield.

And the thing about legal wrangles is that they have a wonderful capacity for making rich men extremely angry.

On November 13th, the two antagonists come face to face during legal proceedings.

The Duke makes a disparaging remark about a witness.

Mohun takes offence.

He answers back.

And here’s the extraordinary thing.

The actual exchange is almost comically trivial.

No thrown punches. No overturned tables. No swords flashing in the courtroom.

Just a disagreement about whether a witness is an honest man.

But honour, in this peculiar aristocratic world, is a dangerous commodity.

Words are exchanged. Feelings are injured.

And Mohun issues a challenge.

A duel.

Two mornings later, the gentlemen assemble in Hyde Park.

It’s November 15th, 1712.

Early. Around seven o’clock.

Imagine that November morning. London not yet properly awake. The trees of Hyde Park. The damp ground. The cold air.

And four men arriving with swords.

Four, because each duellist has brought a second.

Mohun’s second is General George Macartney.

Hamilton’s is Colonel Hamilton.

And these aren’t the sort of seconds we might expect today, standing discreetly to one side, ready to intervene.

Oh no.

They’re going to fight too.

Indeed, according to one account, the Duke invites his second to take part in what he calls the dance.

The dance!

What a wonderfully chilling word for what’s about to happen.

And now the swords come out.

Mohun and Hamilton face one another.

Their seconds engage as well.

And this isn’t some elegant fencing exhibition. No carefully choreographed exchanges, no gentlemanly display of technique.

This is savage.

The two principals attack furiously.

A contemporary described them as fighting like enraged lions.

Thrusting. Stabbing. Trying to kill.

And within minutes, both men are on the ground.

Lord Mohun has been grievously wounded.

He dies there in Hyde Park.

The Duke of Hamilton is also terribly wounded.

He manages to get to his feet, but he cannot go far.

He too dies.

Two aristocrats.

One legal dispute.

Two corpses.

And the most extraordinary thing is that the killing doesn’t end the story.

Because now comes the accusation.

Did Mohun kill the Duke?

Or did someone else deliver the fatal wound?

Hamilton’s second accuses General Macartney, Mohun’s second, of stabbing the Duke after the main fight was effectively over.

Murder, in other words.

Not a fatal wound received in a duel, but a treacherous thrust.

Macartney flees the country.

London is in uproar.

And politics immediately joins the party.

You see, Mohun is a Whig. Hamilton a Tory with powerful Jacobite connections.

Hamilton had been preparing for an important diplomatic mission to France.

And suddenly there are allegations that this wasn’t merely a duel.

That it was something altogether more sinister.

A political assassination.

Even Jonathan Swift gets involved, furiously denouncing Macartney.

But was it true?

Well, the medical evidence and the coroner’s findings pointed towards Mohun having inflicted the fatal wound.

And when Macartney eventually returned and stood trial, the allegation of murder was not sustained.

He was convicted of a lesser offence connected with the duel.

The exact circumstances of Hamilton’s death were fiercely disputed at the time.

And there’s still room for argument.

But there’s no argument about one thing.

Charles Mohun was dead.

At last.

A man who had spent much of his adult life quarrelling, bullying, duelling, drinking, fighting, and repeatedly escaping the consequences.

This time there was no friendly jury of fellow aristocrats to rescue him.

No pardon.

No second chance.

And I keep coming back to the delicious irony of it.

His father had died as a result of a duel.

And now the son had gone the same way.

Like father, like son.

Except that Charles Mohun had made rather more of a career of it.

So next time you walk through Hyde Park, spare a thought for that cold November morning in 1712.

Four men with swords.

A quarrel over an inheritance.

Two dead aristocrats.

And one notorious scoundrel who had finally encountered the one opponent he couldn’t escape.

His own mortality.

This is London. This is London Walks.

See you soon. Saturday at high noon at the very latest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *